REVIEW ARTICLE | Nov. 7, 2026
The Coloniality of Access to Justice: Individual Standing and the Democratic Legitimacy of the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights
Ayokanmi Kehinde Akinbuluma
Page no 325-336 |
https://doi.org/10.36348/sijlcj.2026.v09i11.001
The African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights was established to strengthen continental judicial protection of human rights. However, access to its jurisdiction remains partly dependent on State consent. This paper examines whether the conditional nature of individual standing under Articles 5(3) and 34(6) of the Court Protocol affects the distribution of procedural authority which is between States, rights-holders and the Court. And what this reveals about the Court’s democratic legitimacy twenty years after its establishment. The study employs doctrinal legal analysis, treaty interpretation, examination of the Court’s jurisprudence and institutional analysis. Although it had limited comparative reference where relevant. Reading the Court’s rules of access through the lens of coloniality and democratic legitimacy. The focus is on the connection between the substantive rights and the ability to bring a case before the Court at the continental level. The study shows that the Protocol does acknowledge that individuals are subjects of rights, but denies them the same and autonomous path to the Court in countries that do not accept or have withdrawn their declarations of Article 34(6). Although indirect access through the African Commission provides an alternative route, but referral remains institutionally controlled. It does not place the individual in the same procedural position as a direct applicant. The study therefore identifies a persistent State-centred distribution of procedural authority that can weaken the participatory dimension of the Court’s legitimacy. It recommends stronger Commission referrals, greater acceptance of direct jurisdiction, safeguards for proceedings affected by withdrawal, and clearer limits around the use of State consent as a condition of individual access.
REVIEW ARTICLE | Nov. 13, 2026
From the Last Hope to the Lost Hope of the Common Man: Nigerian Judiciary on Trial
Donatus Onuora Okanyi*, Ugochukwu Charles Kanu, Michelle Marchie
Page no 337-348 |
https://doi.org/10.36348/sijlcj.2026.v09i11.002
In all democratic nations of the world, there are three distinctive arms of government; the executive, legislature and judiciary. These organs, though having separated powers, work collectively for effective governance. The primary objective of the judiciary, which is the third arm of government, is interpretation of laws made by the legislature. The judiciary is often regarded as the ‘last hope of the common man’. The reason for this is not far-fetched; as far as human beings exist, there is bound to be conflict and there need to be an unbiased arbiter for the resolution of such disputes. The judiciary is constitutionally saddled with the responsibility of settling such disputes. In the adjudication of disputes, be it between individuals and states or vice versa, there are immutable principles to be followed to guarantee justice and instill confidence in both litigants and the society, the absence of which will lead to loss of hope in the judiciary. The ultimate aim of adjudication is justice. The true test of fair hearing is the impression of a reasonable man who was present at the trial; whether from his observation, justice has been done. Unfortunately, the Nigerian judiciary has placed itself in a very questionable position over the years, forcing the citizens to begin to interrogate, whether indeed, the judiciary is still the last hope of the common man or whether it has become the lost hope of the common man. This article seeks to juxtapose this age-long assertion vis-à-vis present-day realities in Nigeria where the judiciary has come under heavy criticisms for failing to live up to its constitutional mandate of protecting the rights of all, particularly the common man. It ends with recommendations on how to restore the lost confidence of the common man in the judiciary.
In 2015, China amended its Legislation Law, granting local legislative power to cities with districts (i.e., prefecture-level cities with subordinate districts). These cities have carried out legislation in light of local conditions, which has affected local economic and social development. This paper examines the status quo of local legislation in cities with districts, analyzes issues in its implementation that warrant further research, and discusses possible approaches to improvement, with a view to providing references for relevant research and practice.